A public misconduct hearing has begun for Judge Shelley M. Richmond Joseph of the Boston Municipal Court, who is facing serious allegations that could lead to her removal from the bench.
What Happened?
In 2018, Judge Joseph allegedly allowed Jose Medina-Perez, an undocumented immigrant who had previously been deported twice and was facing drug charges, to exit the courthouse through a back door—avoiding ICE agents who were waiting in the lobby to detain him.
Federal prosecutors initially charged her in 2019 with obstruction of justice, but the charges were dropped in 2022 after she agreed to refer herself to the Massachusetts Commission on Judicial Conduct. The Commission has now brought ethics charges against her, accusing her of willful misconduct and actions that brought disrepute to the judiciary.
What’s Going On Now?
The misconduct hearing centers on a 52-second off-the-record sidebar conversation during the court proceeding. During this time, defense attorney David Jellinek claims he asked for permission to escort his client out the back door. Jellinek, who has been granted immunity, testified that Judge Joseph agreed to the plan.
However, Joseph’s legal team insists she did not authorize the escape and thought the defendant was being taken to a holding cell for further discussion. They argue that Jellinek’s credibility is questionable.
Why This Matters
- This high-profile case could set a precedent for judicial accountability in politically charged immigration matters.
- It reflects growing tension between local court systems and federal immigration enforcement, especially when ICE agents operate in courthouses.
- The case is drawing national attention, particularly after Judge Hannah Dugan in Milwaukee was accused of similar actions earlier this year.
What’s at Stake?
Judge Joseph could face suspension or removal from the bench if the Commission rules against her. Although she avoided federal criminal penalties, the misconduct charges remain serious and may end her judicial career.
